Nashville Coin Gallery Reviews

Nashville Coin Gallery
Nashville Coin Gallery
Nashville Coin Gallery has been in the industry for several decades but their lack of transparency and specialization prevent me from recommending them to others.
Fees & Charges
Customer Service
Honesty & Transparency
A+ rating on BBB
Risk of hidden fees and charges
Lack of transparency
Limited online presence
No Trustpilot rating
Expert Score

What is Nashville Coin Gallery?Nashville Coin Gallery Locations, Timings, Email, Phone, Services

Nashville Coin Gallery, founded in 2002 by Pete Dodgea, is a nationally known and highly respected dealer in rare coins, paper money, and precious metals bullion products, with annual revenue in the millions of dollars.

Nashville Coin Gallery, according to the company, lives on word-of-mouth referrals and online reviews from its many satisfied clients, many of whom are repeat customers. This reciprocity of loyalty is met with the highest respect and gratitude from the gallery’s end.

Nashville Coin Gallery’s foundation has been founded in the pursuit of a unique blend of top-tier customer service and outstanding pricing, setting a standard unmatched in the coin and precious metals industry.

The Brentwood location has evolved into an exclusive appointment-only engagement in which the gallery works directly with customers to provide a more personalised experience. The gallery’s strategic position, around 10 miles from downtown Nashville and 8 miles from Franklin, demonstrates the gallery’s commitment to accessibility.

  • Address: 500 Wilson Pike Circle, Ste. 227, Brentwood, TN 37027
  • Phone: (615) 764-0331
  • Email:
  • Website:

People Behind Nashville Coin Gallery: CEO, Owner, Co-Founders & MoreWho owns Nashville Coin Gallery? What is the management team behind Nashville Coin Gallery?

The company’s website mentions the following team members:

Pete Dodge: Founder

Nashville Coin Gallery owner Pete

Pete is the owner and founder of Nashville Coin Gallery. He is a lifelong coin collector from Brockton, Massachusetts, who was first exposed to the hobby as a child while in the Cub Scouts.

After working as a computer programmer/analyst for many years, including in the United States Air Force from 1980 to 1984, Pete decided to make his lifelong hobby a full-time business and founded Nashville Coin Gallery in 2002. Pete is our Head Numismatist, and he is the primary buyer and seller of coins, paper money, and precious metals bullion products at Nashville Coin Gallery.

Pete enjoys travelling, creating music, and playing guitar and piano in his spare time.

Jonah Nestadt: Coin & Bullion Buyer

Nashville Coin Gallery team member

Jonah was born in Sydney, Australia, where he got a bachelor’s degree in International Business from Macquarie University. He then worked at a coin store in New Jersey for four years before joining Nashville Coin Gallery as a coin and bullion buyer in February 2022.

Jonah enjoys hiking, mountain biking, and listening to live music in his spare time, and he has backpacked in several countries across the world.

Jackson Taylor: Accounting / Finance / Marketing

Jackson is another Nashville Coin Gallery employee who has been with the company since February 2016. He attended Mississippi State University and majored in economics and accounting. His responsibilities at Nashville Coin Gallery mostly include marketing, bookkeeping, online SEO, and data analytics. He’s also been known to help out the Shipping Department when they’re in need.

Jackson enjoys golf, basketball, and powerlifting.

Brian Roan: Shipping & Receiving Specialist

Brian was born in Illinois but grew up in the Dallas area, graduating from high school in Richardson, Texas, just outside of Dallas. He moved to Tennessee in 1990 after spending time in Virginia and Oklahoma and started working at Nashville Coin Gallery in May 2022. Brian is an avid amateur photographer who enjoys photographing birds, flowers, and other animals when he is not performing shipping and receiving chores for Nashville Coin Gallery. He also enjoys travelling with his wife.

Sylvia McMillan: Accounting / Payroll / Human Resources

Sylvia moved to the Nashville, Tennessee area in 2020 and was still working part-time from home for a company in Washington doing real estate work when she became interested in investing in precious metals, so she came to Nashville Coin Gallery numerous times to buy gold and silver. She showed interest in joining their team after becoming fascinated by the firm itself, like the way the company conduct business.

Sylvia joined the Nashville Coin Gallery team in November 2022 and working in the Accounting & HR department, where she is responsible for accounting functions, payroll, and human resources.

Sam Mizell: Photography & Videography

Sam joined the Nashville Coin Gallery team in November of 2020 as a Shipping and Receiving Specialist. He manages all things related to shipping and receiving for a year and a half, from assembling boxes to packing and securing the contents, from ensuring every box is adequately insured to generating shipping labels, from ordering shipping supplies to videotaping all shipping and receiving activities.

During his time, Sam also became highly skilled at coin photography and website video production. However, he quit the organization in early May 2022 after taking another full-time position in the music industry.

Nashville Coin Gallery Products: Bullion Coins, Bars, And Rare CoinsAll products offered by Nashville Coin Gallery

Nashville Coin Gallery offers a diverse range of numismatic products and precious metals. Here’s a list of the product categories they provide:


Nashville Coin Gallery Gold Coins
  • Gold Coins (Various denominations and historical periods)
  • Gold Bullion Bars (Assorted weights and refineries)
  • Gold American Eagles
  • Gold Canadian Maple Leafs
  • Gold Krugerrands
  • Gold Austrian Philharmonics
  • Gold Chinese Pandas
  • Gold Australian Kangaroos


Nashville Coin Gallery Silver coins
  • Silver Coins (Different designs, eras, and countries)
  • Silver Bullion Bars (Various sizes and manufacturers)
  • Silver American Eagles
  • Silver Canadian Maple Leafs
  • Silver Britannias
  • Silver Austrian Philharmonics
  • Silver Chinese Pandas
  • Silver Australian Koalas


  • Platinum Coins (Assorted designs and origins)
  • Platinum Bullion Bars (Various weights and brands)
  • Platinum American Eagles
  • Platinum Canadian Maple Leafs


  • Palladium Coins
  • Palladium Bullion Bars

Rare Coins:

  • Collectible U.S. Coins (Historical coins, key dates, and unique varieties)
  • World Coins (Coins from various countries and time periods)
  • Certified Coins (Graded and authenticated by professional grading services)

Paper Money:

  • U.S. Paper Currency (Banknotes of different denominations and historical significance)
  • World Paper Currency (Currency notes from around the globe)

Other Precious Metals:

  • Other Bullion (Such as bars and coins in various metals)
  • Coin Supplies (Albums, holders, and accessories for coin storage and display)

Special Collections and Sets:

  • Commemorative Coin Sets
  • Limited Edition Releases

It’s important to note that the availability of specific products may vary over time, and it’s recommended to visit their official website or contact them directly for the most up-to-date information on their product offerings.

Beware of Gold IRA scams. Recently several scams have been charged by the authorities. Companies such as Regal Assets, Safeguard Metals and Red Rock Secured defrauded hundreds of retirees like you and me. I strongly suggest you learn how to identify gold IRA scams. You can request a free guide using the button below:

Can You Invest in Nashville Coin Gallery IRA?Do They Offer A Precious Metals IRA?

To invest in a precious metals IRA through Nashville Coin Gallery are the general steps:

  1. Open a Self-Directed IRA

    Select an IRA company that handles opening precious metals IRA accounts and fill out an application. You can work with Nashville Coin Gallery to recommend an IRA company and provide the necessary paperwork. However, I don’t recommend doing so.

  2. Fund Your IRA

    Once you have selected an IRA company, you can move your funds into your new IRA account. You can work with the IRA company representative to transfer or rollover funds into the new account.

  3. Select a Precious Metals Dealer

    One of the forms you need to fill out along the way is typically called a Buy Direction Letter. This is where you list the precious metals dealer you have selected, such as Nashville Coin Gallery.

  4. Decide Which Precious Metals to Purchase

    You can choose to invest in gold, silver, platinum, or palladium for your IRA. There are some restrictions regarding fineness requirements and allowable coin types, so it’s important to get guidance from Nashville Coin Gallery in this area.

  5. Place Your Order

    Once the funds are available in your IRA account, you can call them to place your order for the desired precious metals.

However, I don’t recommend opening an IRA with Nashville Coin Gallery. Why? Because there are plenty of better options available for you.

Opening a precious metals IRA is a major decision. That’s why I suggest checking out our top gold IRA providers list. There, you can find the best precious metals dealer in your state and choose accordingly.

Also, the list will help you understand what the industry’s best has to offer and what you might miss out on.


Nashville Coin Gallery Fees and Charges: Do they overcharge?What are their fees? Do they have hidden fees?

It’s important for people to know about fees and charges when they’re thinking about investing in things like coins and precious metals. However, Nashville Coin Gallery’s website doesn’t give clear information about these fees, and that might make potential customers and investors feel disappointed.

When you’re thinking about investing your money, it’s really helpful to have all the details about how much things will cost. Not having this information on the website can make people uncertain about whether to invest or not. It’s like not knowing all the costs before you buy something – you might end up surprised by extra expenses you didn’t expect.

Even though Nashville Coin Gallery has a good reputation and happy customers, not knowing the fees upfront can create doubts for those who want to understand everything before making a decision. This could also lead to worries about hidden fees that nobody likes.

Transparency is Important

All gold IRA companies are NOT the same. We’ve done the hard work for you and found the most transparent gold IRA company with the highest rating by customers.

Nashville Coin Gallery Reviews and Complaints: BBB, Yelp, GoogleRead all the Nashville Coin Gallery reviews & complaints

Better Business Bureau (BBB)

Based on two customer reviews, Nashville Coin Gallery has an A+ rating and a 3/5 rating on the Better Business Bureau website. The company has been in business for 20 years and has been accredited since 2007. One of their customers posted a negative review saying they should be arrested for robbing people, while another customer praised the company.

Nashville Coin Gallery  reviews on BBB
Nashville Coin Gallery has received #6 complaints on Google

The company has received several unresolved complaints from customers. There are also several unresolved negative reviews on different platforms. Our #1 rated gold IRA company has ZERO unanswered complaints on BBB.


Nashville Coin Gallery has a 4.8/5 star rating on the Yelp platform, based on 10 customer reviews. Customers have mostly posted positive reviews, appreciating the company for providing excellent customer service and being open and honest with them.

Nashville Coin Gallery reviews on Yelp rating platform

Google Reviews

On Google, the company has received many reviews from customers, both positive and negative; however, the majority of customers have left positive reviews saying that the owner, Pete Dodge, responds professionally and is transparent and helpful to them. It is important to remember, however, that customers have also posted negative reviews.

Nashville Coin Gallery customers reviews on Google

Overall, the company has an insufficient online presence, and there are no client ratings and reviews on Trustpilot, which could be cause for concern for potential customers. Having a solid internet presence is essential for client trust and Nashville Coin Gallery’s online visibility is not so good.

Positive Reviews

#1. Linda, a customer, described her great experience with the company, stating that the owner Pete was a wonderful guy to work with. It was her first time, and Pete helped set her at ease by explaining value, and condition, and answering all of her questions. Linda further stated that the company gave her more than she expected in return for her collection. Lastly, she said she would recommend this company to anyone looking to sell or purchase coins.

#2. Another customer, Ammon S., also shared his experience, adding that the drive to the company was worthy. Pete was kind and quick in handling the coins he sold. Lastly, he added, he got better deals than he could have received anywhere else.

#3. Mary stated that she liked her overall experience with the company and its owner, Pete. Pete was really polite and accommodating on the phone, she stated, and in person, he was happy to share his expertise on the coins he had. At last, she added, surely would recommend this company.

Negative Reviews

#1. A customer, Charles advised that you should not sell your silver and gold here since you will get a higher price elsewhere. He described it as the biggest rip-off he has encountered in years. Lastly, he recommended avoiding doing business with this company.

#2. Another customer, Herman, stated that his experience was terrible and that the staff was rude and short-tempered. He also stated that it is not a coin company, but rather a little office with a table.

#3. Gerald, a customer, explained his terrible experience with the company, starting with its owner Pete, who appeared to be in a hurry to run errands rather than carefully evaluating customer’s coins. He also added that he is sure Pete cheated him on his coin. Pete told the customer that his foreign coins were worthless and he did not even look at them. When the customer returned home, he looked up the coins and discovered that it was a $10 Spanish coin. At last, he advised everyone not to do business with this company.

Is Nashville Coin Gallery Legit? Should You Invest With Them?Is Nashville Coin Gallery a scam or legit? Are they worth it?

No, I don’t recommend investing with them.


  • A+ rating on BBB


  • Risk of hidden fees and charges
  • Lack of transparency
  • Limited online presence
  • No Trustpilot rating

I believe you have numerous better options available for you.

Nashville Coin Gallery has been in the precious metals business for 20 years. On the Better Business Bureau, they have an A+ rating with 3 stars. However, little information on fees and charges has been revealed by the company, and there are few customer reviews.

Before you make any final decision, I recommend checking out our top gold IRA providers.

There, you will find out what the industry’s best has to offer. Also, it will ensure you make an informed decision.

Or, you can check out the best gold dealer in your state below:

Each state has its regulations and rules, so we’ve sorted and found the best Gold IRA company for each state.

Find the best Gold IRA company in your state